Main Content

Most Expensive Homes Sold On Staten Island 2019

Year in Review. Here’s Staten Island’s top Luxury Residential sales of 2019

Staten Island has an abundance of luxury homes, making record breaking sales.


76 Romer Road

76 Romer Road, Staten Island, NY 10304

6 Bedrooms- 12 Bathrooms- 8,182 sqft

Sold: $4,500,000

Sold on May of 2019 with Kristina Gershteyn and John Saraceno as the listing agents, this magnificent luxury colonial comprised of stunning architectural details is situated on one truly unique and beautiful property. Located in one of the most sumptuous spots on all of Staten Island, it’s more than just a house, it’s a local celebrity. Perched high above the ocean on the Eastern side of the island, in a sought-after neighborhood of Todt Hill, this mansion will take your breath away in more ways than one. Its stellar position affords daily opportunities to take in postcard-perfect sunrises and sunsets observable from multiple balconies and terraces, while having complete privacy. 76 Romer Road will exceed all of your dream home expectations.

16 Buttonwood Rd

16 Buttonwood Road, Staten Island, NY 10304

5 Bedrooms- 9 Bathrooms- 12,860 sqft

Sold: $3,800,000

Recently sold in October of 2019, this elegantly designed gated estate is built for the most sophisticated buyer. With the utmost attention to detail, highest quality in construction , materials and finish, words do no justice for this breathtaking 110′ wide, 12,860 sqft European inspired, brand new colonial. With 5 bedrooms suites, 9 baths, banquet sized formals rooms, home theater room, elevator, and massive recreations space,  this is a true piece of art nestled on prestigious hill of multi million dollar estates.

50 Nicolosi Drive

50 Nicolosi Drive, Staten Island, NY 10312

5 Bedrooms- 6 Bathrooms- 6,942 sqft

Sold: $2,575,000

Located in the South Shore end of Staten Island, this custom built modern chic home is in an exclusive waterfront neighborhood surrounded by mansions. With breathtaking panoramic beach views & exceptional architectural detail, you’d love to wake up in this home every morning. Large circular windows bring in an abundance of light and highlight the homes 35 ft ceilings. This beauty has 5 bedrooms, 6 baths, and 2 large balconies overlooking the beach. To make this home even better, it features a  resort style backyard with an in-ground pool, kitchen area, fish pond, custom sand area & gorgeous beach!

5 Cromwell Circle

5 Cromwell Circle, Staten Island, NY 10304

6 Bedrooms- 9 Bathrooms- 7,076 sqft

Sold: $2,425,000

Beautiful palatial brick and river rock stone adorn this homes facade. Situated in a secluded corner of Four Corners and Cromwell Circle in prestigious Todt Hill, this home is hard to resist. Sold on January of 2019, this 7,000 sqft, 6 bedroom, 9 bathroom European colonial was built in 2006 with solid beams of iron steel from the foundation to the attic. This magnificent mansion features vaulted ceilings that soar to 24ft and 57 windows (many floor to ceiling) bring in plenty of natural light. Featuring a grand foyer with a soaring ceiling and stunning Cinderella staircase, you’re guaranteed to feel like royalty in this home. Just when you thought it couldn’t get any better, the center hall has glossy Italian marble floors and an extravagant motorized crystal chandelier.  Truly a gem.

25 Ottavio Promenade

25 Ottavio Promenade, Staten Island, NY 10307

4 Bedrooms- 5 Bathrooms- 5,590 sqft

Sold: $2,130,00

An Award winning all brick European style 4 bedroom, 5 bathroom custom home located in one of Staten Island’s most prestigious waterfront communities offers the epitome of elegance. As you enter the grand 2 story foyer you are immediately greeted with the elegance attention to detail given throughout the homes’ 5,500+ square feet of living space. Sold on December of 2019, this is the perfect home to spend the holidays in!