Staten Island has plenty of bakeries with a variety of options to fulfill your cravings. With a bakery on every corner, your sweet tooth will always be satisfied.
Here’s a list of top bakeries according to Staten Island Residents
- Mark’s Bake Shoppe, 3479 Richmond Rd
Owner Mark has been in the familiar with the baking industry since the age of 15 recently pursuing his dream and opening a bakery with his wife in Richmondtown. Baked fresh daily, their bakery is home to a variety of Cakes, Pastry, Breads, Donuts and more! They also offer a variety of personalized Occasion Cakes, Custom Cakes, and Ice Cream Cakes!
You can also find them on the menu at Shake Shack at the Staten Island Mall and their new location at the Empire Outlets ! “The Empire Shack Back” is a vanilla custard, Mark’s Bake Shoppe Nutella pretzel cookie, and salted caramel sauce. Or catch them on Netflix making an appearance on Sugar Rush this past Holiday season in November of 2019.
- Annadale Bakery, 821 Annadale Road
Opening in 2016 by the former owners of Tropiano’s Bakery, customers love their rainbow cookie cupcakes. With 37 years of baking experience their options range from donuts, cakes, pastries and cookies to breads and homemade focaccia pizza.
- Moretti Bakery, 640 Forest Avenue
Located in the heart of West Brighton, customers love this bakery for their custom cakes. Moretti Bakery is guaranteed to bring your cake vision to life.
- Buono Bakery, 1117 Hylan Blvd
This small Italian- American bakery on Hylan Boulevard is a real underrated hidden gem. If you crave a good fig cookie and cheesecake then this is the spot for you.
- Cake Chef, 957 Jewett Avenue
Some of the best cookies you can find on Staten Island. Providing small batches to insure freshness, this family owned and operated bakery has been running for 30 years using ingredients used are delivered fresh daily to ensure a high quality product. They also carry a full line of breakfast pastries!
- Piece A Cake, 177 New Dorp Lane
This restaurant like bakery offers a cafe like atmosphere offering a range of cookies, cakes sandwiches and milkshakes in an industrial space.
- Mother Mousse Bakery, 2175 Hylan Blvd & 3767 Victory Blvd
Around since 1983, Mother Mousse Bakery expanded their delicacies of only mousse cakes to now offering a variety of cakes, cookies, pies and cupcakes. Mouther Mousse is considered to be Staten Island’s favorite place for pastries made with the finest and fresh ingredients.
- Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe, 1899 Victory Blvd & 4366 Amboy Rd
Serving Staten Island since 1970, this pastry shoppe has been run by 3 generations of the Campitiello family serving Staten Island’s Best Cannoli for 45 years along with fresh delicious pastries, cakes and breads.
- Royal Crown Bakery & Cafe, 1350 Hylan Blvd
Royal crown offers a sit down eating experience with the display of deserts right next to you for one to chose from. After your done enjoying one of their many dishes you can finish it off with one of their delicious pastries.
- Renato’s Pastry Shoppe, 1646 Forest Ave
Family run since 1978, unlike others, this pastry shoppe is open every day! Customers highly suggest their lobster tails.
- Sweet Life Bakeshop, 1676 Victory Blvd
According to Staten Island residents, their favorite pastries from this bakery include their cheesecake cones and coconut cakes. However, this bakery specializes in custom cakes, donuts, coffee, homemade Pop-Tarts, specialty breads and so much more!