Main Content

5 Most Expensive Homes Sold on Staten Island in 2020

Staten Island has an amplitude of luxury homes, making this year’s performance in sales stupendous. These lavish homes are not only the owners dream but the realtors as well. All of these extraordinary mansions remind us how to appreciate architecture. And it’s no surprise they are all located in Staten Island’s very own Beverly Hills – Todt Hill, reserved to a privilege view. 

95 Circle Road (Photo Credit via SIBOR MLS)


95 Circle Road, Staten Island, NY

7 Bedrooms – 11 Bathrooms – 17,175 sqft

Sold: $4,850,000

This one of a kind Circle Road estate was sold on December of 2020 being Staten Island’s most expensive home sold! Behind the gates is an all brick center hall colonial situated on nearly 2 acres of flat, astounding property. Located in the opulent neighborhood of Todt Hill, this mansion is a real life dream. Having multiple terraces and balconies, makes it effortless to watch an exceptional sunrise or sunset. This private oasis features a 25X50 gunite pool, a separate pool house with a wetbar, an oversized patio and an expansive lawn area. No need to book a flight anywhere in the summer because this mansion is its very own vacation spot. This truly is a home that has it all. This listing was represented by Laird Klein Sotheby’s International Realty.

32 Highpoint Road (Photo Credit via SIBOR MLS)

32 Highpoint Road, Staten Island, NY

5 Bedrooms – 7 Bathrooms – 7,800 sqft

Sold: $2,350,000

Recently sold in November of 2020, this eminent Dutch Manor estate comes with the uttermost privacy. This hidden gem on the hill was built in 1975 and has an importance wooing to detail. With 5 bedrooms suites, 7 baths, gorgeous formal dining room, primary suite with dressing room, Jacuzzi, walk-in closet, in-ground pool and plenty more! We hope this stunning colonial has endless memories being created. This listing was represented by Connie Profaci Realty.

80 St James (Photo Credit via SIBOR MLS)

80 St James, Staten Island, NY

4 Bedrooms – 7 Bathrooms – 4,284 sqft

Sold: $2,875,000

Waiting behind the gates of Todt Hill is the lifestyle that you have only fantasied of…West Coast design meets East Coast living. This recently renovated and professionally decorated home is located only twenty minutes from New York City on reputable Todt Hill. This exquisite mansion was sold in November of 2020, boasting custom automatic wrought iron gates and heated driveway.  The exclusive backyard is filled with tranquility that has two separate entrances. It’s construction was a year in the making and cost 500K to complete, featuring travertine patios (one enclosed and one open) with a view. Adding to the personal oasis is a heated salt water pool with an automatic cover, a hot tub which sits above the pool featuring a waterfall spilling into the pool below, a swim up bar, lounge area, and a cabana to top it off. Only one can truly appreciate the value and lifestyle in person. “An entertainer’s vision.” This listing was represented by Connie Profaci Realty.

32 Circle Road (Photo Credit via SIBOR MLS)

32 Circle Road, Staten Island, NY

5 Bedrooms – 10 Bathrooms – 12,426 sqft

Sold: $3,450,000

This majestic brick Neo colonial Georgian architectural masterpiece was sold in May 2020. Much is to discuss about this magnificent multi-million dollar home. Featuring volume ceilings, double story grand foyer with cinderella dual staircase, luxurious marble flooring, Brazilian cherry with custom inlays, all mahogany library with built in book cases and its all better than what you see in the movies. Every detail has been meticulously crafted making everything absolutely breathtaking. This listing was represented by Connie Profaci Realty.

120 College Place (Photo Credit via SIBOR MLS)

120 College Place

5 Bedrooms – 6 Bathrooms – 5,200 sqft

Sold: 2,500,000

Sold on July 2020 by Kristina Gershteyn of Team KG Homes at Robert Defalco Realty, this all brick center hall colonial features a captivating interior space that is richly decorated with inlay work, striking hand painted details and opulent finishes throughout. This building stands as the finest example of the most beautiful houses on the prestigious Todt Hill. An immense residence built in 2005 is the jewel and a masterpiece in its own right. The house has multiple balconies and terraces framed with columns and elaborate aluminum railings for relaxing and enjoying the views. The uniqueness of this property is a remarkable product carried out by the building team. The beautifully landscape of the outdoor space is just striking. This is a perfect home to host family and friends on special occasions!

You can call any of our team members to help with your real estate needs!

xoxo SIL