Main Content

10 Most Expensive Homes Sold On Staten Island in 2023


Embark on a tour of Staten Island’s most opulent homes of 2023, each exceeding a 2 million dollar price tag. These residences redefine luxury living across the island. From breathtaking estates to architectural marvels, this elite selection showcases the pinnacle of real estate extravagance. Stay tuned for the grand reveal of the single most expensive home sold this year, as we distill the essence of unparalleled grandeur in Staten Island’s high-end market.


51 Romer Rd, Staten Island, NY 

Todt Hill 

 Sold: $4,600,00

Indulge in the epitome of luxury at 51 Romer Road, a prestigious residence exuding timeless elegance. This magnificent single-family home, built in 1999, spans 6,250 sq ft across two levels, boasting 4 bedrooms and 7 bathrooms. The opulent interior features a primary bedroom with a fireplace, a spa-like bathroom with a Jacuzzi and skylight, and formal dining and living rooms, both adorned with fireplaces. The chef’s kitchen, designed for culinary connoisseurs, is complemented by an eat-in area. A full basement, equipped with a wet bar, enhances the entertainment possibilities. Central air ensures year-round comfort. The exterior delights with a balcony offering water views, a patio, and a fenced yard on 0.54 acres. Parking is a breeze with a built-in garage and off-street spaces. Additional structures include sheds, and the property is equipped with a satellite dish. Impeccably maintained and existing in excellent condition, this residence is not just a home; it’s an architectural masterpiece awaiting the discerning buyer.  Kristina Gershteyn  from Team KG Homes proudly represents this exceptional offering.


99 Buttonwood Rd, Staten Island, NY 10304 

Todt Hill 

Sold: $3,550,000

Discover another luxury at 99 Buttonwood Rd, Staten Island, a meticulously designed colonial residence offering an extraordinary blend of sophistication and comfort. This 7,200 sqft home, built in 2002, features 4 bedrooms and 6 bathrooms, including a primary bedroom with a fireplace, jacuzzi, and a walk-in closet. The interior showcases formal dining and living rooms, a chef’s kitchen with an eat-in area, and a private suite with a bidet, full bath, jacuzzi, and a separate shower. The expansive property spans 2.30 acres, providing a private oasis with a fenced yard, balcony, outdoor grill, and an in-ground pool. With six parking spaces, including a built-in garage, this residence offers both convenience and luxury. The exterior, adorned with a patio and sprinkler system, offers captivating water views, enhancing the overall appeal of this exceptional home. Listed by James Finnegan from Keller Williams Realty Staten Island, this unique property invites you to experience the pinnacle of high-end, custom-built living. This luxurious listing is brought to you by Kristina Gershteyn  from Team KG Homes.


61 Direnzo Court, Staten Island, NY 10309

Prince’s Bay

Sold: $2,500,000

Step into luxury at 61 Direnzo Court, a custom-built 2-family colonial in Princes Bay that transcends elegance with its 10,240 sq ft of meticulously crafted living space. This palatial estate, situated on two lots with professionally landscaped grounds, exudes opulence from the grand circular driveway to the unique 2-story drive-thru portico. The interior showcases exceptional woodwork, distinctive ceilings, and high-end finishes, including a gourmet kitchen flooded with natural light, Brazilian cherry hardwood floors in the great room with a custom wet bar, and a masterfully designed second level. The sprawling backyard features an in-ground pool, paver patio, and ample lounging space, creating a private oasis. With versatile spaces in the finished basement, a detached oversized 2-car garage, and a ground-level 1-bedroom apartment, this South Shore gem is a rare and unique find, representing the pinnacle of sophisticated living. This listing is represented by Robert Defalco Realty !



70 Utopia Ct, Staten Island, NY 10304

Todt Hill

Sold: $2,395,000

Located in a quiet cul-de-sac, 70 Utopia Court presents a recently renovated masterpiece on a spacious 128×81 lot. This stunning Colonial home, constructed in 1998, boasts an impressive array of amenities and luxurious features. The grand ballroom foyer welcomes you with a crystal chandelier and a circular stairway, setting the tone for the opulence within. The first floor reveals a dining room with custom built-ins and a gas fireplace, a formal living room with coffered ceiling and fireplace, a sunroom with wall-to-wall windows, and a family room with custom features and a fireplace. The gourmet kitchen, adorned with top-of-the-line appliances, showcases quality craftsmanship. Upstairs, the main suite is a retreat with separate his and her closets, a spa-like bath with a steam shower and Jacuzzi tub, and three additional bedrooms with en-suite baths. The third level offers a perfect in-home office space. The tranquil yard features low-maintenance grounds, an in-ground gunite saltwater pool, and pavers. A three-car garage leads to the finished recreation room with a 3/4 bath, completing this exceptional home. Represented by NextHome Prestige.


44 Annfield Ct, Staten Island, NY 10304

Todt Hill

Sold: $2,375,000

Next, we welcome you to the epitome of luxury at 44 Annfield Court, a Todt Hill masterpiece presented by James Finnegan of Keller Williams Realty Staten Island. This architectural gem boasts opulence with Versace tiled flooring, a gourmet kitchen, and a grand foyer with soaring ceilings. The living area features floor-to-ceiling windows, a fireplace, and French doors leading to a private terrace. The primary suite is a retreat with a walk-in closet and spa-like ensuite. The lower level offers entertainment with a wet bar and 1100-bottle wine room. Outdoors, a landscaped yard with a patio, outdoor kitchen, and heated spa creates a perfect oasis. The property, spanning 12,000 square feet, includes an oversized garage with a car lift. Modern technology and comfort converge, defining 44 Annfield Court as the epitome of luxury living.
This listing was brought to you by Prereal Prendamano Real Estate.


6 Romer Rd, Staten Island, NY 10304

Todt Hill 

Sold: $2,300,000

Step into luxury at 6 Romer Road, where custom Indian-crafted double doors open to a haven of opulence. The majestic foyer, adorned with a sparkling chandelier and granite flooring, introduces an open floor plan that seamlessly unfolds. Lavish furnishings grace the formal living room, ballroom, dining area, and kitchen on the main floor, with the kitchen boasting custom cabinetry and a terrace with breathtaking views. The second level hosts a primary bedroom with a spa-like en-suite bath and four additional generously sized bedrooms. The lower level offers distinct areas for relaxation and entertainment, including a home office, full bathroom, family room, wet bar, and access to the beautiful backyard. This luxury residence, featuring 5 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms, is an embodiment of sophistication with amenities such as walk-in closets, central vacuum systems, and fireplaces throughout. Parking is convenient with a built-in garage, and the exterior showcases a sprinkler system, deck, patio, and fencing, all on a 0.35-acre lot with water views. Represented by Kristina Gershteyn from Robert Defalco Realty. 


62 Copperleaf Ter, Staten Island, NY 10304

Todt Hill

Sold: $2,250,000

Step into the epitome of modern luxury at 62 Copperleaf Terrace, a custom-built, award-winning colonial nestled on a quiet private dead-end street in prestigious Todt Hill. Completed in 2016 by a premier custom home builder, this all-brick and stone masterpiece exudes sophistication with top-of-the-line materials. Boasting 4 bedrooms and 6 bathrooms, each bedroom having its private bathroom, the residence spans 6,641 livable square feet, featuring a 2-car garage and a beautifully finished walkout basement with two additional potential bedrooms. With close proximity to the Richmond County Country Club and Golf course, this home leaves no expense spared, offering a rare find in a prime location. The interior showcases formal dining and living rooms, a chef’s kitchen with an eat-in area, and a primary bedroom with a jacuzzi and walk-in closet. The total structure area is 5,120 sq ft, providing ample space for comfortable living. Parking is convenient with a built-in garage and off-street options. The exterior features a balcony and deck, fenced yard, and a lot size of 10,000 sq ft. With a meticulous design, excellent condition, and a construction year of 2016, this residence stands as a must-see, move-in-ready haven for those seeking the finest in high-end, custom-built homes. This unique listing is brought to you by Coldwell Banker. 


129 Coverly Ave, Staten Island, NY 10301

Emerson Hill

Sold: $2,221,988

Perched atop the hill, 129 Coverly Ave presents a breathtaking custom all-brick two-story Center Hall Colonial, offering a panoramic vista that is truly priceless. This 8,000 sq ft residence showcases unparalleled quality of workmanship with Brazilian Cherry floors, coffered ceilings, solid core doors with brass hardware, Waynes Coating, and a custom eat-in kitchen adorned with marble countertops and a Thermador stove with an Anzel System. The home features a large formal dining room, formal living room, an elevator, and a master bedroom suite with a dressing room, 4-piece bath, and jacuzzi, opening up to terraces with spectacular views. The top floor provides a finishing touch with awe-inspiring views, while the finished basement boasts a spacious sitting room with a fireplace, wet bar, and a ventilated cigar room. With 12 zones of radiant heat, Pella windows, and a list of amenities too numerous to mention, this property stands as a testament to the utmost finest in quality and craftsmanship. The exterior reveals a custom in-ground pool with an electric cover, pavers throughout, a 2-car heated garage, a heated driveway, and meticulous landscaping. With 4 bedrooms, 7 bathrooms, and an array of luxurious features, this residence is an embodiment of refined living at its peak. This listing is brought to you by Prereal Prendamano Real Estate.


11 Cromwell Circle, Staten Island. NY

Todt Hill

Sold: $2,205,000

Nestled in the heart of Todt Hill, 11 Cromwell Circle beckons you into a world of refined luxury. This all-brick custom colonial boasts a two-story grand foyer, Brazilian Cherrywood floors, and double-height ceilings, creating an open and airy ambiance. The open concept floor plan features an impressive chef’s kitchen with Subzero refrigerator and Viking double-oven, a formal dining room, and a captivating living room with an exquisite marble mantle fireplace. The main floor hosts a first-floor primary bedroom, while the upper level boasts three additional spacious bedrooms. The fully finished basement offers additional living and recreational space, an office, and a bonus bedroom. Step into the backyard oasis with a paved patio, surrounded by lush landscaping. Conveniently located for a quick commute to Manhattan and Brooklyn, this grand residence is more than a home; it’s a testament to timeless elegance and modern convenience. Represented by Kristina Gershteyn from Team KG Homes, Robert Defalco Realty.



54 Shore Acres Rd, Staten Island, NY 

Shore Acres 

Sold: $2,150,000

Lastly, we introduce you to a magnificent mansion situated on a private lake with incredible views in the middle of a bustling city. Experience the epitome of Staten Island luxury with this exquisite Colonial residence, a harmonious blend of sophistication and comfort. Boasting 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, including a lavish primary suite with a dressing room and fireplace, the 6,02 sq ft interior features formal dining and living spaces, complemented by an inviting kitchen with yard/deck access. Revel in the warmth of multiple fireplaces and enjoy water views from the fenced yard and patio on the expansive 0.62-acre lot. Additional structures include sheds, and parking is effortless with a built-in garage and off-street options. Meticulously maintained since its 2002 construction, this home is a beacon of existing excellence, enhanced by modern amenities like central air and a security system. The Exclusive Right To Sell agreement ensures dedicated representation in the real estate market, offering a unique opportunity to savor the pinnacle of Staten Island living in this Colonial masterpiece. This listing was Sold by Kristina Gershteyn  from Robert Defalco Realty. 




If you aspire to become the proud owner of a stunning property on Staten Island, contact Team KG Homes for an unparalleled experience. Our dedicated team members are ready to assist you with all your real estate needs.

xoxo, SIL